Posted by
statesrights on Tuesday, September 02, 2008 4:03:46 AM
I often complain of the different issues that produce American idiots or cause my countrymen to allow the abuse and injury of their rights. Many times I wince at our country's almost united stupidity towards its own history or failing to responsibility maintain the rights and traditions needed to guarantee liberty, independence, and security.
This rant is towards America's strange and misguided love affair and understanding of 'reality TV.' I can't believe that millions of Americans still honestly believe that their votes count on American Idol. I can't believe that most Americans don't argue on behalf of the likelihood that not only are all the contestants of the talent show pre-chosen based on their characters and their ratings level but that the winners and losers and how they will win and loose are pre-decided by the show's producers. This truth first came to me when the She bang she bang Chinaman appeared on an aired audition a few years ago. It seemed hardly conceivable that of the many thousands of Americans who do have a talent for singing, that a guy with so little talent should so happen to appear in front of the three main judges (each judge worth double-digit millions). His appearance was a curve ball, a ratings work of genius. Never mind the fact that many of the arguments between the judges appear scripted.
Why would American Idol script these auditions and performances and results so painfully? It is because the network and the producers have so many millions of dollars invested in it. How much money it will earn or how popular the show will continue to be hinges completely on the auditions, performances, victories, and defeats featured at the center of the show's theme. If the public did have as much say in the show's outcome as we are made to believe, then the producers would have no way of providing the best season possible. The producers, in their pre-decisions know already which contestants would draw the most viewers and which victories or defeats would cause the most drama. Reserving the season's structure to public votes would cause chances that those who profit the most would rather avoid.
I think that the reason Americans are not raising their eye brows towards these obvious contradictions of what reality TV is simply because...they do not care. Whether rigged and scripted or not, America still gets its show. This would explain why wrestling, as obviously fake as it is, continues to grow in popularity. Watching some wrestling the other day I could not believe in how outrageous it has become while involving detailed quarles between wrestlers and WWE managers, personality feuds and challenges between wrestlers. Drama, real or not, is awesome.
The other day, I also watched an episode of Brooke Knows Best. It is one of many "off shoot" reality shows appearing these days. (Reality series stemming from a previous one like for example I love NY from Flava of Love). Just as with countless other reality series, Brooke Knows Best (an offshoot of Hogan Knows Best) is presented as a pure and honest day by day life of Brooke Hogan living in Miami. Yet, it only took a few minutes for me to realize just how scripted her series is. The first clue is the one that seems to deface every other reality show. The characters and even the extras constantly go about as if there are no group of producers or cameras present. I've seen an actual set of a reality show before and there are many shades of lights, sizes of cameras, and types of people with clip boards and mics. Have you ever wondered just how these characters seem to wake up in the morning with fabulous hair and soft makeup?
If it were a true reality show, the people along the street or at the beach would gawk or wave to the camera. It is what people do. People don't just see a scene of Brooke Knows Best or The Osbornes go by them without doing a double take!
The second and just as obvious clue is how every little situation, argument, or problem seems to happen and work out as if it were...scripted. Honestly, peoples' lives, even celebrity's lives are not that interesting day to day. A true reality show would be boring for the most part.
In this episode of Brooke Knows Best she and her female roommate were having issues with their newest roommate. This guy was such a slob and he looked the part. He slept nude in the living room and he woke Brooke up in the middle of the night to ask how to turn on the hot tub for him and his date. Can you imagine that ANYBODY would sleep nude in Brooke's living room with the knowledge that a reality show was being filmed there? Even if it was a self-promoting stunt on his part, it was not natural, and he was not as clueless as the scene made appear. Alsot, would somebody as famous as Brooke accept a room mate like this or at least kick him out after the first of these signs? Can you imagine anybody waking up Brooke Hogan in the middle of the night to figure out how to turn on a hot tub, especially while being filmed? It was clear that this guy was not only paid but also asked for these performances. The show demanded his role.
I do not lay awake bothered by the fact that America buys into the phony production of reality tv nor do I suffer more than a little that our whole culture is being turned on by a strange version of the blood sports of Roman times when battles and scenes were staged to look real for the public's entertainment. Instead of blood, these modern-day Roman entertainment thrives off drama, backstabbing, drug and relationship issues, and other forms of the human illness.
Yet, sometimes I am concerned that all this reality entertainment is having more of a bad influence on America other than just a distortion of reality and sliming of values and dignity. Since reality TV really started becoming popular with Survivor, Americans have become more seduced, entranced, and obsessed with television than ever. The evidence is clear in the number of camera flashes that surround Paris Hilton or Linzy Lohan. (Following the dysfunctional lives of celebrities is becoming a reality TV clique in its own right becoming more and more popular).
Is this recent fetish of reality tv culture damaging? Can it be one of the causes why we the people have allowed so many of our rights to be axed and have allowed so many of our public leaders to continue to be corrupt, abuse their powers, and tax and spent beyond our consent? I ask this because I have heard more than a few novel Americans chime that our country does not care what state it is in as long as American Idol is still scheduled. It also seems that before reality television became the phenomenon that it is now, Americans were much more aggressive with making our leaders accountable for corruption or lies. Before the age of reality TV we forced the resignation of Nixon because of crimes his staff committed. Before this time we impeached President Clinton for lying about a sexual experience outside his marriage.
Yet, since this reality tv dynasty began, we have allowed our current president to invade Iraq without congressional support or declaration. We've not impeached him for using false information to invade and conquer a whole other country that caused thousands of deaths of our troops and hundreds of thousands of unarmed civilians. We've not held Bush accountable for carrying on a war beyond the goal he set of capturing Sadam Hussein. We've stood by while he continued the war years beyond his public declaration that the mission had already been accomplished. We've not only allowed but we re-elected him. And now Americans have ushered two men, McCain and Obama onto our ballot, who show virtually no promise of being the people's representative or becoming an ardent defender of the people and the constitution. And we did not protest enough against the media when it made its own conscience decision to censure and silence a candidate who had the qualities of liberty and justice in his heart, Ron Paul.
Was revolution, revolt, riots, or tea parties sacrificed by the seduction of Reality TV culture? The timing of it along with the timing that so much started going to hellsbells seems more than a coincidence.
Nay, it is true that this isn't the first period in our history that we have allowed bad things to happen. Did American citizens not also allow the Lincoln Adminstration's armed invasion of the Southern states for executing their right of secession? Did we not also allow our government to conduct an armed take over of every native settlement out west? The thing is, the only reasons why those things happened was because the citizens just wern't succesfull in preventing it. The difference between now and then was that then, there were plenty of Americans who aggressivly stood by their principals especially when their government contradicted them. Defeat was not dishonor, for again, Americans always try. In one example where many Americans campaigned on behalf of their rights and values was the late 60s, the protests against the War in Vietnam. Sometimes the people was succesful and sometimes not.
These days even the public protests have lost their bite.
Another fact that causes me to wonder about Reality TV's role in the direction of our country was in an earlier part of this discussion. For hundreds of years, Rome was a republic and its course was decided by its tradition of democracy and elections. However, about the same time that the Roman empire's territory was at its greatest expanse, during the period when Rome was the greatest world power, just as America is today, it also started to decline. Now the arrogance of being so powerful and victorious played only a part of its demise. What really vaporized the empire from the earth forever was when its citizens forfeited their responsibilities and power to a few just as we have forfeited many of our rights and responsibilities to our government. Those few that included Nero and other corrupt and faulty emperors could not help but allow the empire to fail. That is what happens when something is trusted to such incompetence. Why did the Roman citizens allow all their rights to bleed away and for the security and future of their empire to be given to so few, so unqualified? Around the same period when Rome changed from a republic to an empire and then to nothing, Roman citizens were engrossed and blinded by gratifications and excess. The most notorious of these distractions were the public and private orgies and the great gladiator shows performed for VIPs and the simple people alike. The people became so involved in their own self interests and what made them feel good that they lost all control over their empire. This may have been the plan all along for those then who sought such power.
I wonder today, if the same isn't happening in our society. The average American appears to care more about the next episode of John and Kate plus Eight than they do about the disturbing direction our country is going in at the hands of incompetent leaders. In fact not even global warming is taken as seriously as the most high and mighty liberals think it should. All in all, most Americans do not go any further than blogging about an issue rather than working to fix it. I stand accused.